Copywriting

by Jef van de Graaf

jef@hxcopywriting.com

#004

Tipping the Scale in Your Buyer’s Head

The same moment without the scale: Jef in a straw hat throwing
                  two peace signs at the camera in a lantern-lined room in Kumamoto. An AI rendition of Jef holding a traditional balance scale, a
                  mound of rice on one pan and brass weights on the other.
This isn’t my best AI-altered image, but it does a good enough job capturing the story you’ll read in a moment. If you’re curious, this photo comes from my bicycle tour across Japan—I think I was on a date with a cutie from Tokyo while passing through Kumamoto.

TL;DR: Copywriting does not force people to want things. It influences people’s decision-making and how they weigh their options, risks, and timing.


Hello again,

When I was living in Japan, I spent my weekends wandering through old traditional markets. I always loved watching the shopkeepers use those classic balance scales—sliding a small brass weight along a beam until it perfectly balanced out a bag of fresh Koshihikari rice.

Buying was straightforward. You’d tell the shopkeeper how much rice you wanted. They’d align the weights and then fill a tray until it balanced. If it was a good shopkeeper, they might throw in an extra scoop—tipping the scales in your favor and, hopefully, encouraging you to keep coming back for more.

Physical scales like that don’t exist when people buy online. Instead, when someone opens your email, lands on your sales page, or reads your ad, an invisible scale drops down inside their mind.

But what exactly are they weighing?

They’re trying to decide whether they should buy, find another vendor, or give up and go home empty-handed.

Mathematically, that mental scale looks a bit like this:

Value > Cost + Friction + Doubt

If the left side (Value) is empty while the right side (Cost, Friction, Doubt) is heavy, the chance of a sale is zero. But when perceived value heavily outweighs the burden on the right, buying becomes the path of least resistance.

Now, I know this isn’t perfect because buying decisions are complex.

But here’s a breakdown of the psychological weights that make buying easier on the left, and friction points you need to target with your copywriting on the right:

Left Side

Value Drivers

Financial Value

  • Cost Savings / Discounts vs. Alternatives
  • Immediate or Long-Term ROI
  • Resource Efficiency (Money Kept)

Functional & Quality Value

  • Superior Quality, Craftsmanship & Durability
  • Convenience, Speed & Ease of Use
  • Premium Features & Flawless Performance

Emotional Value

  • Peace of Mind & Relief from Stress
  • Joy, Pleasure, or Novelty
  • Energy & Health Optimization

Identity & Social Value

  • Prestige, Status & Pride of Ownership
  • Alignment with Personal Values & Beliefs
  • Community Belonging & Social Proof
Right Side

Buying Barriers

Cost

  • Sticker Price / Initial Investment
  • Hidden / Ongoing Fees
  • Opportunity Cost (Money Spent Elsewhere)

Friction

  • Complex Checkout / Long Forms
  • Steep Learning Curve & Onboarding
  • Slow Delivery / Hard to Implement

Doubt

  • Skepticism (“Will it actually work for me?”)
  • Fear of Regret / Making a Mistake
  • Unclear Guarantees or Returns

Social & Internal Risk

  • Fear of Looking Foolish to Peers
  • Resistance to Change / Break Habits
  • Buyer’s Remorse

Obviously, human psychology is never perfectly linear, and every prospect brings their own set of hidden variables to the table.

It’s also impossible to account for everything you see in the table above. You could try taking a screenshot and asking your AI to identify where the scale is tipping against you and brainstorm ideas to adjust the weights (and how you write about them) in your favor.

Or you could hire a copywriter to do that for you instead.

To your success in business (and life),

Jef van de Graaf The human behind
HX Copywriting

p.s. Let’s go back to the market for a minute. If you’re located in a spot with no foot traffic, no matter how good your product (or copywriting) may be, no one’s going to buy it. At the same time, you could be in a hot spot but people just walk on by. Not everything people sell on the market is worth buying. So again, copywriting can only help so much. If you have a product or service nobody wants or needs, nothing is going to save you from going broke or bankrupt.

Read my letters from your inbox

All letters are written by my human hands. You can unsubscribe anytime.